Category: For business

  • I lost a $58M deal and my client still won

    I lost a $58M deal and my client still won

    image

    “We’re in. Let’s do the term sheet.”

    Friday morning. Happy days.

    After more than two months of near-daily contact, I called Mark.

    No answer.

    I messaged him:

    “We did it. They’re in.”

    An hour passed.

    I looked at my wife and said, “This isn’t right. This isn’t how people respond. He’s going to walk.”

    She was aghast.

    Four days later, after a weekend of being ghosted, he pulled out via email.

    Everyone involved was stunned.


    Coffee, eggs and money

    It began in the private dining room at the Botanical Hotel in South Yarra – “we haven’t been able to land the finance for one of our clients – it’s over $50M, can you make that happen?”

    Niche market. Asset-backed. Complex proposition. Solid fundamentals and a genuine legacy play. Yes, I can make that happen.

    My contact put me in touch with their client Mark, and we bonded over shared interests, industry experience, and a desire to get things done.

    Contracts went back and forth over a week, then we got into it.

    The first thing to solve was the gap between the project sponsor (Mark) and the sophistication of the capital stack he needed to interface with.

    Whilst ‘build it and they will come’ works well for most industrial plays in Australia – and don’t we love commercial property as wealth hubs – ‘just let me build it’ doesn’t stack when you want someone to go on risk for $50M+ in a niche play.

    Having the land and debt free title is a great start, though if you’ve ever driven a manual car and missed a gear, that grinding sound of the mismatched cogs – that’s what happens when you don’t give an Investment Committee (IC) what they need to make a decision, or even before that, your internal contact what they need to bring it up with the IC.

    Where the fund was managing over a billion dollars, and running along in 4th or 5th gear, Mark was in 1st; and you can’t go from 1st to 4th!

    We had to get into 3rd, or at least 2nd gear, and that’s what I did with Mark and my internal contact at the relevant finance fund over two months.


    How To Set Sail To The Promised Land

    If you want to build a ship, don’t drum up the men to gather wood, divide the work, and give orders. Instead, teach them to yearn for the vast and endless sea. – Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

    I first heard that from a friend in 2015 when we did the Landmark Forum and Advanced program together; they are about creating reality through language, taking total responsibility for one’s life and enrolling people in new possibilities, which are the fundamentals of making big things happen.

    When it comes to your business, family enterprise or version of legacy and impact, people need to believe in your dream – not only that it is possible – that you are capable of delivering them to the promised land;

    Where are we going, how strong are the waves and winds? If people drown, who will take over? Have you built a boat before? That didn’t leak? Who in the team can fix a boat?

    What about the people where we are going? Do they know you? Are they eagerly awaiting your arrival – have you traded with at least a few of the more well-known ones before?

    Your proposition takes verifiable work, which the lawyers and accountants in the room refer to as ‘due diligence’ or simply DD.

    This tension between verifiable DD and dreaming of possibility is where we can play with and argue about valuations – let’s face it they are made up – even the most basic equation of a company being worth two or three times earnings relies on a future where the leadership sticks around to make it happen.


    Specifically, what did we validate in this deal?

    Constrained and heavily regulated supply, massive and growing demand, a long time for competitors to get established, heavy NIMBYism (Not In My Back Yard) for new developments, all great stuff if you’re a new entrant that can deliver – contrasted with being ‘an alternative investment’ (meaning it’s not stocks, bonds or cash) so a limited potential audience of private equity / venture capital to back it, a cash intensive build and an asset that requires specialisation to implement and operate.

    Then we got into the leadership team and the strategic partners in the market that would support whether the project was inundated with sales or sidelined, the different state and federal regulations related to the conduct of sales and considerations for asset renewal and long term maintenance and profits.

    With that locked away, it was finding a truly independent expert that has led this particular industry, knows what it takes to deliver because they’ve successfully done it themselves, that would validate the proposition and that isn’t the project sponsor!

    This was really interesting to me, because from the funder’s perspective, what wouldn’t someone say to get their dream built?


    Open The Right Doors

    A genuine shout-out to LinkedIn here, which I joined in 2007 – that’s two-thousand-and-seven.

    It has definitely had waves of appeal, though I adore how powerful it is to interact with people like you, dear reader, and it’s a great way to find those previously mentioned independent experts.

    For nearly twenty years I’ve had the privilege to connect with significant leaders across every kind of industry in many places of the world, and at least 80% of my network has been met in person through attending business meetings or conferences.

    I also don’t pitch people when we connect, and value who they are and seek to learn about them over time.

    In turn, generally when I ask for help, because I’m not trying to foist a sale on them, they help – it’s human nature.

    This is how I get to independent industry experts, or anyone really, within 2 phone calls, and if capital is a big requirement of your version of legacy, investors want to know three things;

    1. How much do you want?
    2. What are you going to do with it?
    3. When do I get it back.

    If you can explain that and it holds up to scrutiny, you’re halfway there.

    The other half is knowing the investor’s mandate, because most people get it backwards – if their mandate doesn’t match what you’re pitching, the whole thing is irrelevant.

    I was pleased to successfully match my client in this instance with the first fund I contacted.


    Why did I lose a $58M deal?

    In simplest terms, the project sponsor got ‘an offer they couldn’t refuse’ to walk away, rather than taking on the challenge of managing significant debt and a 2-3 year journey to realise the project’s potential.

    From day 1, we’d been discussing what their version of a good life, generational wealth and legacy meant to them, and every time we had a Zoom meeting I could see hand drawn pictures from the kids on the wall – the offer they got took care of all three, and that’s enough.

    We’re only here for this one precious life; some of my clients are creating or transforming empires, some are focused on a single transaction; all are valid.

    It’s about defining what your version of legacy looks like.

    Then making it happen.

    If there’s a significant opportunity on your horizon, but you don’t have the bandwidth, connections, experience or capital to realise it alone, that’s the conversation I’m here for.

  • I’m now an Accredited Advisor with the Family Business Association

    I’m now an Accredited Advisor with the Family Business Association

    Assumption is not consent – it will bring your family enterprise unstuck, I’ve seen it time and again, and after a lifetime in family business myself it was good to make it official!

    I got to learn in person from one of the world’s best in Dennis Jaffe, with great support from Chris Graves of the Family Enterprise Group at Adelaide University, and have now joined the Family Business Association (AU)’s accredited advisor team spread around Australia.

    As the current or emerging leader of a family enterprise, consider;

    – Before asking ‘who should take over?’ the better question may be ‘what do we want this business to be for?’ – underneath that sits what’s it all actually for? What do satisfaction, impact, legacy and a life well lived mean to you, and does the business serve that, or is it the thing you serve?

    – The structures set up years ago for good tax reasons are making decisions in the background; who gets paid and who doesn’t, who’s effectively in or out – are your family living with unintentional guardrails that could do with a review?

    – If you’re genuinely successful and wealthy enough for the previous two questions to have a material impact on your circumstances, then what change will you make in the world beyond the family?

    The pillars of a good family enterprise include strategy, people, legacy, and access to the capital to make it happen – I wish you the very best with yours.

    Dennis Jaffe and Philip Bateman
    Dennis Jaffe and Philip Bateman
    Learning with the FBA
    Learning with the Family Business Association

  • The Most Innovative Investor Strategy Development Firm in Australia (2023) Bravo Charlie

    The Most Innovative Investor Strategy Development Firm in Australia (2023) Bravo Charlie

    Bravo Charlie Most Innovative Investor Strategy Development Firm 2023
    Bravo Charlie Most Innovative Investor Strategy Development Firm 2023

    I’m very grateful that Bravo Charlie has been awarded the Most Innovative Investor Strategy Development Firm in Australia for 2023.

    • January 2024 will be our 15th birthday 🥳
    • We’ve deployed 8 versions of my Investor Engagement System® for clients
    • In a few weeks Australia’s most well known Impact Consultancy will go live with theirs

    In recent years I’ve had the privilege to work on the strategy and craft the storytelling for CEOs, Executive Teams and Stakeholders of several Australian Impact Investment Award Winners;

    2018 Impact Market Builder of the Year
    2019 Impact Asset Manager of the Year
    2020 Impact Market Builder of the Year
    2021 Individual Outstanding Achiever of the Year
    2022 Individual Outstanding Achiever of the Year

    Consistently I find passion, rigour, domain expertise, innovation, a love of the game, optimism in the face of adversity and a tenacity for outcomes in those I work with.

    I’m all about helping them leverage technology to be more efficient and accelerate their impact, to appear at their best on camera in a way that is easily shareable, to have branding, collateral and stories that are world class, built in their own words, with exacting attention to detail.

    No matter what your #investorrelations team, #brandingagency, #marketing department or #publicrelations agency come up with, no matter how slick your CEO is at reading a teleprompter, NOTHING will be as genuine as an unscripted interview, and this is where my work and that of Bravo Charlie stands apart.

    Firstly, we need to create your organisation a market dominating #strategy within a turbulent environment.

    It must be pragmatic, and a living framework within which all decisions are made consistent with the nature and direction of the business.

    Then, we need to ensure the digital tools in your organisation support the effectiveness of your team, not slow you down unnecessarily.

    And finally, I conduct unscripted interviews with your team and stakeholders, asking leading questions that elicit responses which paint the picture of your strategy.

    We then edit these into sharp, engaging shorts, layed out logically in a customer journey and integrated throughout websites, information memorandums and collateral, backed by analytics and relevant automation.

    Voilà, your Investor Engagement System®

    Everyday I encounter new people, ideas and innovations working to improve our world – I love it and feel like I’m just getting started!

    I could put many people here who I rely on as inspiration, mentors, trail blazers and clients, though particular thanks to Andrew Hollo and Dr. Jodi York, Rosemary Addis and Cliff Prior of The Global Steering Group for Impact Investment (GSG), and Peter Castellas, Climate Zeitgeist and the Climate Salad team for their enthusiastic support in recent years.

    Thanks also to Acquisitions International AI Global Media and Innovation In Business for the 🏆

    – Philip Bateman

  • Launching Asia Society Australia in Melbourne at the National Gallery

    Launching Asia Society Australia in Melbourne at the National Gallery

    A great pleasure to join over 400 guests at the National Gallery of Victoria for the official launch of the Asia Society Australia in Melbourne at the Hawker Ball!

    #hawkerball

    Below:  Dan Andrews, Premier of Victoria, Philipp Ivanov, CEO of Asia Society Australia and Philip Bateman, CEO of Bravo Charlie

    Asia Society Australia Dan Andres and Philip Bateman - Philip Bateman and Bravo CharlieHawker Ball NVG - Philip Bateman and Bravo CharlieFab Deserts - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

  • Hamer Scholarship awarded to Philip Bateman for China

    Hamer Scholarship awarded to Philip Bateman for China

    Our CEO has been awarded a Victorian Government Hamer Scholarship to focus on developing his Asia Capabilities, acting as an Ambassador for Victoria and will be studying Mandarin full time at Suzhou university, near Shanghai, between February and July 2020.

    Philip Bateman, shown below accepting the award from the Hon. Martin Pakula, Minister for Jobs, Innovation and Trade, and Mr Long Zhou, Consul-General of China.

    Philip Bateman Hamer Scholarship - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    The awards night at the Investment Centre, Level 46 Collins St, Melbourne – Philipp Ivanov, CEO of the Asia Society Australia delivering a keynote address

    Hamer Award - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    The recipients of Hamer awards for China

    Philip Bateman Hamer Scholarship Group - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

  • Smarter Impact launches with 40 business & world leaders!

    Smarter Impact launches with 40 business & world leaders!

    I’m really excited to share with you a reference tool for the insights, education and inspiration so many amazing business leaders have shared with me in the last year – from Impact Investing to China relations, Government, Funding and Taxation, Science and Technology, the Arts and Business 101 – 40 interviews available for you in playlists, with more coming.

    Head over to Smarter Impact with Philip Bateman on YouTube, watch a few videos, click like, leave comments, hit subscribe and please share – help me get the momentum building and the message out! 🙂

    Thank you to those featured so far, it’s such a privilege for me to be able to learn from and share your insights – And this is only the beginning! 🙂

    Smarter Impact Launch scaled - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

  • Bravo Charlie are $50K Boost Your Business Grant Providers

    Bravo Charlie are $50K Boost Your Business Grant Providers

    Do you know a Victorian based manufacturing business that has their sights set on the world?

    It is our great pleasure to officially announce Bravo Charlie are Registered Service Providers in the Advanced Manufacturing Stream of the Victorian Governments Boost Your Business voucher program through to December 2019, providing dollar for dollar matched grants up to $50,000 in the areas of Marketing and Branding Strategy for Hong Kong and Chinese markets.

    For funding round dates and availability, visit http://www.business.vic.gov.au/support-for-your-business/grants-and-assistance/Boost-Your-Business/Advanced-Manufacturing-Voucher-Stream

    BCBYB - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

  • Presenting Digital Media Marketing to AMTIL

    Presenting Digital Media Marketing to AMTIL

    As a company member of the Advanced Precision Manufacturing and Technology group, plus an advisor to the Federal Governments Entrepreneurs Programme, we had the opportunity to present a session on Digital Marketing Systems and Story telling for Industrial and Agricultural companies, to both the management of http://www.amtil.com.au/ and their EP advisor group.

    It was a great morning, have a look below;

  • Fuel saving technology hits Australia

    Fuel saving technology hits Australia

    I got back to Melbourne from Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania on Friday – I flew over to see for myself if they were A. honest and B. serious – take a look for yourself;

    The guts of it is the electric axle generates an average of 15% fuel savings, then as an auxiliary power unit engine idling is no longer required and the underbody has an aero effect which further improves fuel efficiency – their road-tested averages deliver 30% fuel savings with routes that contain elevation changes.

    If you’re a fleet owner in Australia, please get in touch directly via 0402 017 700 / philip@bravocharlie.global – we are completing 2017 production planning for Australia and taking non-binding reservation requests that close at the end of October for 2017 deliveries.

    The road to Pittsburgh (from Melbourne)

    I was watching a tech journalist called Robert Scoble broadcast live over Facebook at 3 am in the morning on the 6th of April, 2016 – from there I got in touch with the team and recently flew over to verify everything – I was both impressed and excited to bring this back to Australia.

    About Hyliion (http://www.hyliion.com/pages/about-us)

    “.. As a mechanical engineer and motorsports racer, Hyliion Founder and CEO Thomas Healy set out to bring the advantages of hybrid technology to tractor trailers. His mission was to minimize fuel costs for long-haul, over-the-road delivery fleets by bringing electric technology to tractor trailers in an add-on solution.

    Following wins at business case competitions across the country, interest for the concept grew, and so did investment. The group expanded their engineering team and strategic advisors to include electric vehicle experts, truck and fleet owners, and business leaders. Hyliion’s patent-pending technology has won accolades from the U.S. Department of Energy, Wells Fargo, Rice University, and Shell Technology Ventures, among others..”

    ————————————

    What next? How do you get involved in the Reservation System?

    Currently we are completing non-binding reservation requests for Australian 2017 deliveries – Reservations give you priority to evaluate, purchase, and take delivery of a number of production units.

    While the Reservation gives you priority, it does not constitute the purchase or order of any equipment and it in no way obligates you to complete a Purchase Agreement.

    Based on a completed reservation request, we will ask you to configure your system and choose a financing option prior to the start of production for your Reservation.

    Hyliion will create an order for your system and you will receive a Purchase Agreement indicating the price of the equipment, plus estimates of any applicable taxes, duties, transport and delivery charges, and any other applicable fees.

    Remember, a reservation in no way obligates you to complete a Purchase Agreement, though whilst Hyliion will make their best efforts to accommodate your needs further down the line, Reservations with Purchase Agreements will have priority.

    Why use a Reservation system?

    The company is experiencing a tremendous amount of demand and are dedicated to ensuring this technology is taken to a broad market, which includes Australia.

    Rather than accept offers to give the entire production capacity to a single company, through the reservation system Hyliion are able to complete production planning and balance distribution in the USA, Europe and Australia.

    Okay – I’m in!

    Good to hear – please call me on 0402 017 700 or email philip # at #  bravocharlie.global so I can answer any further questions you have and supply your organisation with a reservation request form –

  • 19th China International Fair for Investment and Trade (CIFIT)

    19th China International Fair for Investment and Trade (CIFIT)

    CIFIT 1 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    The 19th China International Fair for Investment and Trade (CIFIT) was an incredible event, to which the Australian Business Forum team (http://abf.events) and Mr Ray Evans did a terrific job organizing one of the two Australian pavilions –

    CIFIT 2 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    A special thanks to Kate Ritchie, Yao Cheng and the team at http://www.chincommunications.com.au for their help in getting our print material and video translations done – they were exceptional value.

    CIFIT 3 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    During the CIFIT it was our great pleasure to meet with Mr Jeoven Wong, Director General of the CIFIT / Xiamen Municipal Bureau of Convention & Exhibition Affairs –

    CIFIT 4 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    During the event we attended several presentations and match making, though for ourselves as B2B service providers primarily supporting English language businesses, some of the biggest benefit was joining and learning from the group of Australians pioneering their enterprises into Asia;

    CIFIT 5 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie CIFIT 6 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie CIFIT 7 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    Aside from the inter-country antics, high level diplomats and investment meetings, I was very pleased to see wobble-boards and vitamix’s being given the high energy Mandarin sales treatment, along with a host of super high tech gadgets, transport and hydroponic soil-less gardening tech, including kids boxing robots that stood themselves up when fallen over in any direction and the like.

    CIFIT 9 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie CIFIT 10 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie CIFIT 11 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie

    Marian and I look forward to developing relationships with the wonderful people and companies we met, as well as returning to the 2017 CIFIT to further https://philipbateman.com/ ‘s support of Australian companies heading north into Asia.

    CIFIT 12 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie CIFIT 13 - Philip Bateman and Bravo Charlie